Monday, 25 February 2013

Traditionalism



Rene Guenon in 1950Traditionalism is a Sufi/Islam-inspired [but not orthodox Sufism or Islam, despite claims to the contrary - see external linkSedgwick 1999 Traditionalist Sufism ] neo-esotericist movement that was founded by the French scholar Rene Guenon (1886-1951) (photo on left). There is a stromng emphasis on the concept of the Perennial Philosophy, the term "Tradition" refers to the central idea that the great Faiths all derive from a single Primordial Tradition, which itself is directly inspired as on-going Revelation from the Transcendental source. This is in keeping with the Islamic belief that "God has sent a prophet (or Messenger) to every people" All the Great Religions and are therefore merely different expressions of the same Divine Logos, and hence are all equally valid spiritual paths to Salvation. Traditionalism therefore is concerned with the abiding inner or esoteric Truth or Principle that it understands to be at the heart of the various exoteric religious Traditions.
Other Traditionalists include Guenon's student Frithjof Schuon, Titus Burkhardt, Martin Lings, art historian and philosopher Ananda K Coomaraswamy, external link Seyyed Hossein Nasr, the Egyptologist R.A. Schwaller deLubicz, and a number of others. Thinkers sympathetic to the Traditionalist view include mythographer Joseph Campbell and Mircea Eliade, scholar of comparative religions Huston Smith, Indianologist Alain Danielou, E.F. Schumacher, and Prince Charles.
Guénon had a low opinion of modernity which he believed had degenerated from or corrupted the Divine Revelation and authentic spiritual civilization, and other Traditionalists and Traditionalist-supporters tend to share this view.


Frithjof Schuon, and Traditionalism as a mystical path

Frithjof Schuon could rightly be considered the greatest of the Traditionalists; he taught a universalist mysticism based on a common esoteric Truth in all religions and spiritual paths. With Schuon we see Traditionalism, in its Neo-Sufi guises, as a tolerant (as regards all religions and spiritual teachings) spiritual theosophy, emphasising the Logos or universal revelation, and contrasting the exoteric rational mind with the spiritual Intellect, the latter corresponding to the faculty ofjnana or gnosis. His first book, Link to Amazon com The Transcendental Unity of Religions, is still the most influential, although he has written many other works as well.

The Transcendental Unity of Religions
The Transcendental Unity of Religions


Link to Amazon com Other books by Schuon
Frithjof Schuon
Frithjof Schuon, image from external link Frithjof Schuon - Life and Work


Rejection of Evolutionary Science

Traditionalist anti-modernity means the rejection of anything to do with the modern and postmodern West, including, all elements of science that conflict with traditional accounts of the universe. One thus finds Traditionalists like the Islamic scholar Seyyed Hossein Nasr advocating a Creationist viewpoint, because secular evolutionary science is seen to be at variance with the truths of traditional cosmologies. Dr. Seyyed Hossein Nasr goes so far as to flatly deny the possibility of reconciliation between science and religion. See also Kenneth Oldmeadow's essay external link The Firmament Sheweth His Handiwork - Re-awakening a Religious Sense of the Natural Order.

Is Traditionalism Fascist?

There is an occasional tendency among some "fringe" Traditionalists to be affiliated with the Right. Guenon's friend the external link fascist philosopher Julius Evola is often included among the Traditionalists, although Guenon never held fascistic or antisemitic views. The Russian scholar and political activist external link Alexander Dugin (b. 1962) is founder of the contemporary Russian school of geopolitics known as Eurasianism or Neo-Eurasianism, a Putin supporter and the former ideological guru for Edward Limonov's National-Bolshevik Party, although his fascist credentials external link seem to have been exaggerated by the West. There may be a psychological equivalence here - people who want certainty (and hence hate modernity) are also likely to be attracted to strong religious positions (e.g. in the West religious funddamentalists are often (but not always!) to the right of the political spectrum. However, Traditionalism as a whole is in no way fascistic, and one can hardly blame the movement as a whole for the occaisonal malcontent. However, these individuals should not be taken as representative of perennialism as a whole.

Summing up

Perhaps the best way to utilise Traditionalism then is to consider Schuon-style mysticism and his and other Traditionalists' authentic constructive critques of the limitations of exoteric consciousness and sceptical rationalism, while not allowing oneself to be shackled by their anti-modernity and glorification of a romantic past religious Golden Age that never existed.


Web linksLinksWeb links
web pageLinks Tradition - short good intro and excellent list of links
on-line document Traditionalist Sufism by Mark Sedgwick
This article was published in ARIES 22 (1999), pp. 3-24. It takes a very authoritative look at the somewhat uneasy relationships between orthodox Sufism and Islam on the one hand, and the Traditionialist Sufism of Guenon and Schuon on the other. Highly recommended reading for anyone who wuld like to know more about the roots of the modern Traditionalist movement.



Kheper index page
Topics index page
Perennial Philosophy Home

No comments:

Post a Comment

Physicalism Is Dead Alternative views on the mind-body problem are becoming increasingly popular. Updated November 25, 2024 |

 Ref Psychology Today Blog  Key points The reductionist physicalist position entails that phenomenal consciousness does not exist. Scientist...